ABOUT ADS OF THE WEIRD

With Ads of the Weird, MSNBC.com takes a look at some of the oddest, most eye-catching, controversial and just plain interesting advertising out there today. Primary writer Allison Linn covers the retail and advertising industries for MSNBC.com. The Ads of the Weird team is always interested in hearing what ads have caught your attention, whether it's online, on television or in print.


Old Spice horses around

Posted: Monday, September 15, 2008 4:00 PM by Allison Linn
Filed Under:

We’ll say this about Old Spice’s "Double Impact" commercial – once you see it, you aren’t likely to forget it.

In the ad, a centaur – half man, half horse – is in the shower, soaping up and bragging about how he loves Old Spice’s new body wash/moisturizer because he also is two things, "a man, and a pretty smart shopper."

Our narrator then goes on to explain all the benefits of this dual-purpose product before concluding:

"It’s perfect. I should know. I’m two great things. A man…,"

".. and, a provider," concludes a woman who has just walked into the shot.

Image: Old Spice commercial
Old Spice

We get that Old Spice was trying to make a joke by ignoring the centaur element, and we like that the ad doesn’t resort to the usual flashy graphics/hot women/loud music cliché that defines most ads for similar men’s products.

But seriously, "a provider"? Was this ad made in 1965? Or has Old Spice perhaps missed the last few decades, during which when women entered the workforce and also started earning paychecks?

We would have appreciated a more creative punch line.

Sexism aside, there is something to be said for a commercial that is willing to take a risk, even if some people will be too distracted by the centaur to pay attention to the brand at hand.

Old Spice also takes things even further with a Web site that shows the ad’s narrator in all sorts of odd pairings: half-octopus, half-slug, half-snake, etc. In two examples of not-so-subtle symbolism, he is also shown as half-tank and half-cannon.

Click here to go to the Web site and see the ads.

Old Spice also recently launched another new series of ads, called Swagger, that follow the more traditional formula -- use our product and you will be cool and attractive to women! If only it were that easy. Click here to watch those ads.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I beleive the provider part was referring to the sexual organ of a beast. Yo should of probally of knew this, I mean most of the commercials nowadays has sexual references.
very hot ad...even for those of us not into horses
The weirdest thing about this ad is that this manly centaur is half man -- and half mare.

I think they used the word "provider" because they probably couldn't get away with using the word "lover".

The woman's line was an innuendo. I don't see it as a retro-slam against women. If anything it was targeted directly at some men's vulnerablities.

Combine the two - (sultry voice spoken by a woman in a night slip who clearly digs her "provider") + (the bottom half of the man being a horse) = the joke.
On the website the ad keeps repeating itself and there are no women. Is this guy a gelding?
He's a horse! they're not talking about providing financially. They're saying he's got a huge penis!
He's a horse! they're not talking about providing financially. They're saying he's got a huge penis!
the horse is a MARE!!!!  

oh no

is this really ????!!!

i can't believe
Centaurian heh! Now we know why Adam and Eve were kicked out of the Experimental Zoo of the Gods! They used 'Old Spice'!
Thanks to Old Spice we finally know the true meaning of our bizarre ancient history and the missing link of the Garden of Eden.
When I first saw the ads I wasn't sure if they were saying the guy is a horses a##, or that he's hung like a horse?  Either way, the ads are stupid and just a little creepy.
Hmmm, a centaur for a husband or companion..now what could he provide that might tickle my tonsels?
I think the "provider" aspect of this ad is meant sexually, not financially, therefore not ignoring the fact that he is half a horse entirely.  
I don't really find the idea of a man being a "provider" to be inherently sexist (it doesn't rule out the woman providing a few things, too, or doesn't necessarily imply he's the sole provider), and Old Spice has always tapped into a sort of nostalgia. Even the name "Old Spice" conjures up retro imagery (and I must admit I have a soft spot for it, given that my dad used their products every day when I was a child).

I have yet to see the ad, so I'll have to seek it out!
Funny ad, but it is not half horse! half pony maybe, and appears to either a gelding or a filly!  
Is the ad directed at women who purchase toiletries for families?  Does it work?
When I watch that commercial, sexism is the last thing that comes to my mind.  When I see the woman enter and she is obviously his wife, I get a little weirded out because you know someone, in the back of their mind was thinking of Catherine the Great (even though it isn't true).
I'd much rather they resort to the usual flashy graphics/hot women/loud music cliché.  Is creating a memorable ad worth having people remember that it is one of the stupidest ads of recent memory?
Too funny. The horse is not even a male
Ummmm, I thought the term provider was sort of a naughty double entendre.  As in, wink wink, I'm not saying what he "provides" but he is half horse... if you know what mean.
the only thing that bugs me about old spice is the availbility of the original scent.  it does great for me and i'm not a big fan of the new smells.  every company has had some bad commercials and they have really been leaning toward the cheesy side of things recently.  just as these ads is total tounge in cheek cheese.  if anyone is reading social issues into them then they should let go of their hang ups and just laugh at the cheesyness.
Don't you get the "provider" reference? It's racy, appeals to young men.  He's certainly providing her with something, and you didn't reference it above...
I actually found these quite cheeky when I first saw them on TV. However, after reading your analysis, I'm now convinced that it's rhetoric like yours that propagates the notion of "sexism" in taody's society. Perhaps you should have viewed this ad for what it is....an effort to draw humor out of two very dissimilar pairings.  
Oh my goodness! Sexist? Some households do have a house wife with a provider husband. Whats wrong with that? We must learn to appreciate both aspects. I do like the commercial though. I think its funny.Try not to get so sensitive.
I think you missed the not-so-subtle message eg. hung like a horse, sly like a snake, etc (obviously you got the canon and tank reference). And being a provider doesn't necessarily mean a 1960's type man, the modern day male needs to know how to provide for his woman sexually as well as financially (hence the phallic symbolism), and often multi-task by being a father, coach, cook and bread winner (symbolized by the octopus). The internet ads are a lot more subtle which is probably why they didn't make it as main-stream commercials (Bubba in the trailer park just ain't gonna get it). Now I'm no marketing consultant, actually I'm a scientist, but I got all that from the commercial...why didn't you.
I have always found that commercial to be particularly disturbing, not only because of the "provider" comment (what... is this the 1950's?) but because of the centaur. I have to change the channel when that commercial comes on.
dumb - just dumb
Yeah, this ad got my attention, but at the end I wasn't left with any desire to even buy their product. I like the Nivea For Men bodywash ads taking potshots, albeit in a manipulative way, at the typical bodywash commericals.

The advertisers and makers need to realize that a lot of people just buy what's cheapest/on sale. No matter how clever or memorable the ad is, if the product is more than I'm willing to pay and can get a cheaper alternative, that's where my money's going.
Am I the only person bothered by the idea that this chick is having sex with a horse? Maybe i am just a pervert but it was the first thing I thought of when i saw this ad the other night.
He's a "stud", if you get my drift.....
I thought this was a pretty obvious single-entendre about how this guy was a major stud (hung like a horse) and used Old Spice.  The guy is hot.  I loved how they danced all around what they were trying to say.  It's definitely an ad I watch.  But I had a friend who was watching TV with me and didn't get it.  

Um, and most poeple now wouldn't know the diff between an mare and a stallion if it sat on their face.  I reference "Down on the Barnyard" with the bull that has udders.  
Personally, I did get a kick out of the centaur, but that's just because my current crush is a Sagittarian.
Between this horse being a mare and the 'jealous cow' in the chicken sandwich commercials being actually a bull, I really think that someone on Madison Avenue needs to go back for a refresher course in ...wait for it...  'animal husbandry'.  
Really .... didn't say "supporter", as in financial, said "PROVIDER" ... I got the undertone and found it funny without being rude!  great ad!
In reality Old Spice didn't "do" the add.  It was built by the amazing, talented, and award-winning group at Struck design.
See struckcreative.com and be wowed by their artistic prowess and savoir faire.
I find it funny that everyone I know who has seen the add, and apparently everyone who has commented thus far on your blog, took 'provider' to be a sexual innuendo, yet you took to be some kind of passive aggressive form of sexism.  I have to ask, now that the joke has been explained, do you feel a bit silly for crying foul?  Granted it's a dumb commercial and equally ridiculous joke, but I would expect you to saying to yourself right about now, "Oops, don't I feel stupid" for thinking "provider" was anything but a reference to his manhood.
Of course they had to make him look like a gelding. Just imagine the uproar if they had a anatomically correct stallion!!
Leave it to the guy in San Francisco to note that it's half male and half female (mare).  (Yes that's what I said, you figure it out.)  Personally, I find it to be just another stupid commercial pandering to our short term attention span.  And, it has zero to do with the product.
honestly, oh my, get over yourself. because the use the term "provider" now you think that it's an assault on feminism. honestly, this is how far political correctness has taken us. also, women are still seen as the gender to provide the best "nurturing" because last time i check, men were not able to "nurse" babies out of their nipples.
*snorts*  Mike from Spokane, the "guy in San Francisco" isn't the only one that noticed the horse is obviously a mare or a gelding.  Several other posters did, and so did I the first time I watched the ad.  
A gelding would still have certain parts that would show up in the side view: The horse is a mare. I wonder if the masculine front makes the centaur a hermaphrodite?

The octopus is actually a squid. Counting the man's arms, it has ten arms, total. Not an octopus, which has only eight arms.



I just wasted 1 minute of my life. tks
Allison Linn, get off your "high-horse" (yes, old-spice pun intended) and relax with the "womans rights movement" propoganda.  In a world with Hurricane Ike's, wall street fiasco's & hot-air politicians, we could use some CHANGE/REFORM from the "run to a lawyer nonsense" and just, well...  relax... and LAUGH!!  
SO. WHO CARES A COMMERCIAL IS A COMMERCIAL AT LEAST THERE WASN'T SEX, DRUGS, NUDITY, AND MISS Allison Linn IT DOES NOT NESSESARILY MEAN THAT MEN ARE SUPERIOR... THINK TWICE WHEN YOU GIVE YOUR OWN OPINION. THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX FOR ONCE. IN SOME THINGS I AGREE WITH YOU BUT AS A WOMAN TRY TO HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE HUMOR. RELAX.
I didn't even notice that he was built like a mare, (would I want to see an anatomically correct centaur on an Old Spice commercial?!) nor did I take offense that she calls him a provider.  I just thought it was seriously funny, and something that I wasn't embarrased for my kids to see.

I just think it's funny that she wrote,"We get that Old Spice was trying to make a joke by ignoring the centaur element" and thought it was sexism, when she totally missed the ad's point.  Too funny
Those commercials made me shake my head and laugh. The whole series of them are one big double entendre'.  Whoever said the horse was a mare is mistaken. Yes, mares keep the fact that they are female neatly covered by their tales. But geldings and stallions keep themselves quite modestly tucked up inside 99% of the time too. And with stallions, they keep the rest of it nicely tucked between their back legs and unless you lean over and take a gander, you most likely won't see. It's all hidden away out of view most of the time. And yeah, I have an Animal Husbandry degree. B.S. in Horse Management and Reproduction.
Clearly, I am not their target audience/demographic. That was just plain stupid.
I find it difficult that you didn't know that this commercial is a major sexual double entendre.  Seriously, you really didn't get this?
At least they didn't put the cannon and tank ones on TV yet, or at least not that I have seen.  Although adults might enjoy those 2 ads, I wouldn't want my kids to see them.
For those of us in Old Spice's *NEW* target audience--We get it. We like it. And We. Shall. Provide...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):