ABOUT ADS OF THE WEIRD

With Ads of the Weird, MSNBC.com takes a look at some of the oddest, most eye-catching, controversial and just plain interesting advertising out there today. Primary writer Allison Linn covers the retail and advertising industries for MSNBC.com. The Ads of the Weird team is always interested in hearing what ads have caught your attention, whether it's online, on television or in print.


Thick, buttery … insurance?

Posted: Tuesday, April 08, 2008 3:00 AM by Allison Linn
Filed Under: , ,

If you’re a has-been celebrity looking for work - and what has-been celebrity isn’t looking for work, by definition - the good news is that there are other job prospects out there besides lame reality television shows. There’s also Geico.

The insurance company has for some time now been employing the likes of Little Richard, Joan Rivers and even Charo to “interpret” real people’s stories of how well Geico dealt with their insurance claims.

Maybe the well of real D-list celebrities is running dry, because now the company is turning to … a syrup bottle.

Image: Mrs. Buttersworth ad

In a new commercial, Mrs. Butterworth editorializes as a Geico customer recounts her tale of woe - or, actually, her tale of getting a nick in her windshield repaired. It’s not very compelling stuff, but Mrs. Butterworth makes the best of it,  intoning, “Oh, dear, broken glass sends shivers down my bottle!

Mrs. Butterworth isn’t as funny as Little Richard or as annoying as Joan Rivers  , and she likely won’t be as provocative as Charo, whose ad got the company in hot water when the Connecticut attorney general charged that it could have left the false impression that the insurance company can fix cars directly.

Still, the talking syrup bottle gets points for nostalgia.  But what’s funny about the ad – and all the others in the celebrity spokesperson series – is that the “real” customers all but completely ignore their celebrities’ wacko antics.

Also, whereas Little Richard et al appeared comfortable sticking to the insurance pitch, Mrs. Butterworth can’t resist the opportunity to hawk herself. 

“It was a piece of cake. Or maybe more like hot pancakes,” she says of the claim process.

And when all is said and done, she declares, “Now I feel rich. Thick and buttery, too.”

Not surprisingly, the Geico ad comes as The Blackstone Group, which purchased Mrs. Butterworth’s and other brands last year, is working to revive the syrup brand with an ad of its own that offers a trip down memory lane.

 It’s interesting to see a montage of cute kids through the decades, but when it comes to pancakes, we’re still sticking with real maple syrup.

Click here to watch’s Geico’s ad.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Personally...I'd rather watch Mrs. Butterworth than the has-been stars.  At least she brought back some sweet childhood memories.  The stars make me cringe.
Good ole' Mrs. Butterworth...I wonder if her voice fits what I always imagined...a deep, southern soulful one...
...I'd buy insurance from Mrs. Butterworth...
At long last, we finally know the true meaning of the phrase, "Message in a bottle!"  

I can't wait to see the ad with Mrs. B.  I've always liked her.  Would love to see her work with the Gecko - they are about the right size for each other.

Enough "stars"!!  Give me syrupy instead!
Geico has branched out with their commercials, they should stick with the winner they had and come up with new ads with the gecko.
I really liked the add... The Joans River one made me laugh too... As much as I like the Gecko ads, I like the celeb ones too, because it diversifies that appearance of the company and targets different audiances.
Originality appears to be another victim of greed.  Movie sequels, old TV ads, spinoff sitcoms...is there no one with an original idea anymore, or are the powers that be too afraid to take a chance on an original idea lest it doesn't bring in record-breaking profits?  The entire industry needs new blood, new blood with some discernment and courage.
Dammit, now I want pancakes!  And I'm stuck in this office for 2 more hours...
Maybe next time we can have Charo AND Mrs. Butterworth. Sorry, Love Boat was an important part of my adolescence.
How effective are these commercials?  When the one comes on with James Lipton sitting on the side of the pool with his feet in the water - and he says "They asked questions?! How existential?!" - My visual and auditory senses go astray and I literally forget I am watching an insurance commercial!!! LITERALLY!!!
I liked Peter Frampton too. It's definitely a different idea. I was getting tired of the gecko...so a change is nice.
Get rid of Charro and Joan Rivers... Give me Frankenberry and "Mikey" from the Life Cereal commercials.
Dont forget about the "want-to-be race driver" kid on the go kart. I enjoy all the ads. The caveman in the airport still makes me laugh.  
The best part of the ad comes at the end with Mrs. Butterworth intoning "Oh dear, someone has put a logo over my face!". I just burst out laughing at that.
Bring on the damn pancakes!
Mrs. Buterworth is as bad as the one with the Little Person who played "Mini-Me". Sheesh.
I loved the Mrs. Butterworth ad... "Someone has put a logo over my face! :) "  She's endearing, even if she is a talking bottle -- and I'd rather watch her (or any other nostalgic ad-based character) than any of the annoying celebs in the other Geico spots (with the exception of that Police Academy guy... glad to see he's still alive and getting work).
TS - have you seen the latest Geico Caveman commercial where the two cavemen are commenting on the short-live Cavemen television show?!  I imagine that years from now someone might see the new commercial prior to seeing the original commericals and resulting television series and have no clue why it is comical!!!
She's just not the same girl since Charlie Weaver (the original Mrs. Butterworth and grandpa of RoseAnne Arquette) died. Now there was a dirty old man who could put on a dress and make you believe in sweet old ladies.
I fell off the couch laughing the first time I saw the Mrs. Butterworth ad.  This is a sensational campaign that really keeps getting better.  The Mrs. Butterworth spot is really a sendup of sendups, in my view.  It's just great advertising.
Two words: Downright creepy.

As for someone demanding original commercials, Farmers has had some clever, original commercials. Guess my mind is stuck on insurance.
I love the Geico ads, with the exception of Ms. Rivers.  Mrs. Butterworth is a howl and James Lipton sitting by the pool was brilliant.  I hope whoever writes those got a huge bonus.
what the!! a syrup bottle!
Geico has some of the best commercials on the tube.  Very creative and entertaining.  Mrs. Buttersworth is a real winner too!  What's next guys?
I think the GEICO adds with the "celebrities" are the worst adds on TV. The ones with the lizard is cute.
Lame reality television shows they all are-----ain't that's the truth!!!!
@Matt
A "southern, rich, soulful" voice would be Aunt Jemima. Mrs. Butterworth is definitely a cheerful British nanny or maid.
Take a train to Happy Town!  WooWoo!!
Absolutely.... this is one of the best Geico ads! I hate the Joan Rivers ad! .. At first I thought what the heck?? but, rock, glass... makes perfect sense! way to go!
I LOVE Mrs. Butterworths! I read some of the other comments and I too was laughing like crazy over the part where she said there was a logo covering her. That's the best dang commercial I've seen in a long time. I know some people are tired of the gecko, but he has to come back sometime right? After all he fits with the name of the company...
Love these spots! Here's who I wanna see:
- Dwayne Hickman
- Ponch ("Chips" fame)
- Norm
- Art Bell (no, really)
- Roger Clemens (he's not busy)
- John Dean
I love the Geico ads!  Yes, Joan Rivers was a bit over the top, but she is making fun of herself on purpose and those who know how much plastic surgery she has had find her ability to laugh at herself and help others to laugh is a good thing. There are a lot of ads over the years that I have enjoyed, and miss when they stop.  (And I love the happy California cows ads!!)  
Geico hits another home run.  Whoever designed this add needs a raise.  
Mrs. B is an American treasure and I'm delighted to see Her back in the public eye.
I thought this commerical was buttery sweet, good  ole Mrs. Butterworth is still going strong.
At first, it starts out as a typical geico ad with the dulcent-toned announcer presents the latest claimant.  Usually, I'm in the midst of other things becuase who watches commercials, right?  But the comment at the end about the "logo over my face" was the actual moment I looked at my screen.  I rewound my DVR just to play it back and howled!

It's their first clever commercial in a while.
I don't watch TV... who are these people?? I have State Farm and pay about a third of what Geico wanted to charge me. I like pancakes!
As sort of an adman, I really like the Geico commercials. Don't forget the one that started the series off was the "movie announcer" guy. At the end, he nods his head as if saying "Good job!!" funny. And the one with Frampton is funny only because the gal in the commercial is having a very hard time keeping a straight face through it all.
I could watch Geico commercials all day.  Let's get rid of the Hillshire Farms "go meat" and the Ball Park "hunger get what hunger want" ads.  They are the absolute worst!!  And probably the same ad agency since both companies are owned by Sara Lee.
Looks like Geico is is scraping the bottom of the bottle?  I hope Mrs. Butterworth got paid well.
The Geico adds are really NOT funny.  I never went to school for marketing, but I could write a better commercial than the D-list star commercial's, easily.
This appears to be a clever example of product placement WITHIN another advertisement.  I wonder how much the Butterworth people paid towards this advertising campaign.  It's a win-win for Geico: a catchy spokes(wo)man and a subsidization by another company.
These GEICO adds are totally obnoxious and should be taken off the air.
the best commercials were the...

"dramatic music"
Girl (sobbing): Robby just broke up with me!!!
Mother (comforting): Hunny its ok...i have good news.
Girl: He called for me?!?
Mother: No....but i just saved 100's of dollars on car insurance by switching to Geico


and the gecko
I thought the Mrs. Butterworth ad was pretty original.  I watched the ad to see what she would say. I'd much rather watch commercials with has-beens than the stupid caveman commercials.  Who is next, Mr. Whipple?

But neither of them will get me to change my car insurance company if I'm satified with who I have.
No one has mentioned their "tiny house" ad. I thought that was ingenious, too...and a timely poke at reality shows! I agree that whoever is coming up with this stuff needs a raise (or a promotion!)
I think the best Geico commercial was with Little Richard...he cracked me up with his comedic skills with a great musical sense...Little Richard, you still rock.  I also loved Mrs. Butterworth in that commercial, would love to see Parkay margarine tub with his voice...
I adored tiny house.  The rest of the geico adds I could do without.  But Tiny house cracked me up every time.  Seriously, The best part was that every time it came on I thought to myself, gee I can't believe how low reality tv has stooped.  
My office has mammoth TV monitors with no sound - I had to watch the link to hear what she was saying.. and I loved it!  Not only was the voice spot-on, but you know she's got a one-track mind, with everything somehow being related to pancakes.

I go to Vermont too often to buy fake syrup, though. :)
Re: "get off your butt's" comment. You say you don't watch TV. Really? so how are your seeing these commercials?

As far as the ads go, some are funny, some are not. The Gecko and older caveman ad's were definately better.
I'm all warm and buttery inside now!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):