ABOUT ADS OF THE WEIRD

With Ads of the Weird, MSNBC.com takes a look at some of the oddest, most eye-catching, controversial and just plain interesting advertising out there today. Primary writer Allison Linn covers the retail and advertising industries for MSNBC.com. The Ads of the Weird team is always interested in hearing what ads have caught your attention, whether it's online, on television or in print.


Running, we just can’t quit you

Posted: Tuesday, April 01, 2008 3:00 AM by Allison Linn
Filed Under:

When most companies want to sell a product, they try to tell you how fun the product is, how much you need it (even if you never realized it!) or how much more you’ll like doing your favorite activities because you have this great, new item.

The running shoe company New Balance is trying a different approach.

The company’s latest campaign, which launched during the NCAA basketball tournament, begins with an image many can relate to – a man sleeping soundly, only to be forced out of bed for the sake of workout.

“You are in a relationship with running. A love/hate relationship,” the narrator intones.

Image: New Balance
New Balance

You probably think you know what happens next: Our hero will trudge out onto the street, his resolve and joy growing stronger each time his New Balance shoes hit the pavement.

Well, the commercial seems to start off that way, but then it veers into strange territory. The hero’s morning run takes him, incongruously, from a sleepy neighborhood into a futuristic urban jungle, where everything is red-hued, including the water, and the buildings seem to defy gravity.  Soon, he is being chased by other runners, who seem more like bad guys in an action flick than inspiring competitors. Eventually, he flings himself off a building into another futuristic, slightly cartoonish world.

Meanwhile, New Balance keeps hammering home the idea that the sport on which their business relies is, frankly, a bit torturous.

“It is a constant balance. A balance between joy and pain. Work and play. A balance between love and hate. Everything we do is geared towards tipping the balance. This is the new balance.”

The love/hate theme is a risk, but it’s one that’s likely to score points for empathy and realism. After all, most of us do look toward our workouts with a mixture of pleasure and dread, and one would think that counts double for the type of hardcore runners who are most likely to frequently buy high-end running shoes.

But the weirdly lit, futuristic theme is distracting and nonsensical. If the ad is about being honest about the pleasure and the pain of running, why inject fantasy into the mix? The commercial leaves the viewer with too many far-flung questions:  Who are those other, slightly menacing-looking runners? Did global warming make the ocean red? Did the runner do permanent damage to his knees when he jumped off that building (and why did he jump off that building in the first place)?

New Balance is launching several commercials using the same theme of running as your partner in a dysfunctional love/hate relationship. But while the flagship ad distracts us with its futuristic weirdness, the other commercials get our attention with their quirky form of honesty in advertising.

Click here to watch the ad, or click here to see the campaign on the New Balance Web site.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

These ads are tremendous and so true.
It's so funny that you should post this. I just saw the commercial last night and as a hardcore distance runner, I can say I totally identified with it!  I even joked to my husband that I felt like I should start buying New Balance shoes because clearly they "get me." I guess I really didn't notice the futuristic overtones I was so intent on the running relationship love/hate theme. I'll have to watch closer next time. At first glance though, I'd say this is a great direction for New Balance to take. There are enough shoe manufacturers out there that cater to runners who are more focused on fashion than fartleks. I want to buy shoes from someone who knows what I know: sometimes running sucks... but it sucks less if you wear really good shoes!! That being said, I plan to continue wearing my Brooks.
I love the commercials!  The runners who will continually buy 2 or more pairs of running shoes per year will identify with the campaign.  I like that non-runners don't get it.  I think other runners will like that as well.

I will stick with my Supernovas, though.  :-)
I run at 3:30 in the morning and this ad spoke volumes regarding my feelings towards my sport.  I have been buying their shoes for 9 years and they really know their business.  I believe their commercials show that they really know me as a runner.
I run in New Balance (I go through 2-3 pairs a year) and I love this ad! I run early in the morning and my mind does ramble and at times things do seem sureal.  The love/hate relation occurs for me almost every morning and I am at risk for going back to bed up until the moment I lace up.  Then, once out the door, the world is mine and it is exhilerating! I agree with Dan from Iowa, non-runners won't get it and New Balance knows they don't have to.
You underscore the issue with evaluating ads on anything other than impact on profit. There are a thousand opinions about what is right or wrong, good or bad, about an ad. The only objective way to evaluate an ad is by the business results it generates.
My wife and I saw these ads and we love them. I am training for my first half-marathon and these ads really speak to how I feel about running.
I think that this ad is great. I like to view the runners that the main character is being chased by as the ones trying to catch up. When I run with a group I always try to stay ahead, and use the ones behind me as motivation to speed up. As with the ocean being red and running through odd enviroments - well, I think that I speak for a lot of us runners when I say that after running for an extended period of time, odd things start going through our minds. It's a great ad, and I still continue to wear New Balance.
When I first saw these adds it seemed as if they had been made just for me.  They really nailed it...running does suck.  That being said; I gotta go run :-)
Saw this ad last night for the first time-really got my attention. As something of a newbie marathoner (4 last year) I love it.Runnings reward of exhilaration and acheivement is hard won and this ad speaks to that directly.
I am an 'aspiring runner' and totally identified with the ad.  I like many others who have already commented was busy thinking about how the ad hit home - I didn't even put a thought toward any questions about the futuristic scene, odd lighting or 'menacing' runners.  As someone who has spent some early mornings out on the streets and trails I can attest to just how surreal suburubia or center city can appear in the red/pink/orange-hued, quickly changing lighting at sunrise.  As for other runners - most seem to be faster than I, running farther than I or in less pain than I - so perhaps my competitive and envious side does see those other runners thorugh a lense that makes the appear to be less than friendly?  In hindsight, I guess I am realizing that the aspects the author of the article questioned about the ad might actually be the real reasons I identified with it.
The weird surroundings, the building and the other runners are not meant to be frightening, they are beautiful and freightening.  They are artistic representations of the joy and the pain that we experience while running depending on all those factors we are so aware of.  How well did we sleep, what did we eat yesterday, what is the temp and humidity, what is our mood, how far have we run the last several days.  We all have those terrible runs on occasion, but we live for those once-in-a-while perfect runs.  That is what this commercial represents.  
As an exercise coach and health educator, I thought the ads creatively reflected reality.  Exercise -- including vigorous running -- is damn good for you, but sometimes unappealing.  I (and my clients) do it anyway.  A coup for New Balance; relating to running the way a majority of people likely do, instead of through the eyes or perspective of a "star" who no one can truly relate to.  
"After all, most of us do look toward our workouts with a mixture of pleasure and dread, and one would think that counts double for the type of hardcore runners who are most likely to frequently buy high-end running shoes."
Hmmmm...I guess that would depend on your definition of a hardcore runner. I averaged 50-60 miles a week for a few years and truly enjoyed the workouts. The worst days by far were the ones you were forced to take off. Ok the track sessions sucked! Being able to effortlessly run fast and long while high on endorphins is an euphoric experience. You learn to embrace the pain as it is your familiar friend not your enemy. You laugh at steep hills and run up them as hard as you can with the goal of saturating your legs with as much latic acid as you can tolerate. I didn't even consider myself hardcore as many runners run 100+ miles a week. That is hardcore. Running is hard when you don't run enough but once you have put in the work it is sheer joy. If you can find a hardcore runner that doesn't feel that way he is either overtrained or needs to take up another sport. BTW like most runners an ad would never make me switch shoes. After 18 years of training in Nike Pegasus why even think of taking a chance and switching to a new shoe?
So many runners say they identify with the New Balance ad, strange though it is. . . Could this be because the ad-writers are runners, and got their surreal ideas from the extra endorphins generated by the extra stress of 'forced' running??
After reading this article, I wasnt sure what to expect, being that I havent seen the ad.  After watching it, I sure can relate to it!  I think New Balance really framed the subject matter squarely in the minds of "us" runners!  It will be tough to get me out of my Asics though...  :P
I think New Balance's other TV ad about breaking up with running is hilarious! Been there...tried that. Runner's can totally relate
i hate running with a passion, yet i get up lace up my shoes almost everyday and find the pain on occasion is replaced by the feeling of something accomplished, something worthwhile, something that i need to do...........
What Bleary Eyed Runner said.  As any serious runner knows, hard workouts are hell when you're doing them, but you love the satisfaction and results that you get from doing so (ergo the love/hate).  Anything that tips the balance towards love without compromising the integrity of the workouts is welcome.  This was very good advertising.
I got sore just from watching this commercial :-)

As a newbie runner (I'm doing 8K's and 10K's) I'm in an almost constant state of pain... but it's a good pain! This commercial really makes sense to me, as I love being out on the streets in the pre-dawn hours, but I HATE it, too.
Why are you guys over in the U.S. worried about an advert, after all what is it, come on guys get a life. Is this really all you have to talk about, by the way there is nothing wrong with the ad, but with this making head line news is bad. ther is so many other things in life that you should be worried about.
Bleary Eyed Runner said: "There are enough shoe manufacturers out there that cater to runners who are more focused on fashion than fartleks."

What the hell is a fartlek? Sounds like something I get after eating Chinese food...
Fartlek is 'same as interval training' as your MS Word dictionary will explain. Looked it up.
Noticed NB has been running ads which they never had done before. Also noticed they are opening retail outlets. The marketing department must have been given the green light. Have used their products for a couple of decades due to high quality - which is a sure fire way of keeping customers. Just hope the envigorated marketing department doesn't decide to pay for those ads by increasing prices as it is not an inexpensive product already. BTW, even their tennis shoe is superb.
Obviously not a hard-core runner.  Fartleks are short sprints that you do during your run.  You pick a point ahead (maybe 50-100 meters) and speed up so that you're running between 75% to 90% of full speed.  Once you reach the point, you back off and recover at close to your normal pace.  Then, you do it again (or not) as much as you care to.  
"Fartleks are short sprints that you do during your run."

I see, thanks for the definition.  When one suddenly speeds up like that, it could cause one to fart.  Aptly named...
I haven't seen the ad in television, but I will check out the video when I get home (at work now & even writing this is faux-pas).  I totally identify with the concept and congratulate NB for thinking outside the box for this campaign.  As someone who does run and buys at least a couple of pairs of running shoes per year, I love the fact that NB has addressed both the love and dread of running, something I have conflict over on a daily basis.
I get what they're trying to do and it worked... I payed attention. I don't know if I'll buy their shoes though, that big N is just a bit too goofy looking.
I was a competitive distance runner for almost 10 years and I think J Doe said it best: "Being able to effortlessly run fast and long while high on endorphins is an euphoric experience." Running can be very demanding but its returns are tremendous in both physical and mental well-being.
Running sucks!
Nothing menacing about this ad, except for maybe the slight paranoid feelings most runners experience when approached by other runners- every other runner seems faster, in better shape, and better trained. Yep, definitely need to run another mile today.  NB got us.
Fartleks are named after the coach who innovated them.  I think he was German or Scandinavian.  As a 10-11 miler per week (3 5-6k runs per week, just to stay in shape) I do identify with the commercial.  It's not just running though.  I have been lifting weights for the past 26 years (nowadays about 4 hours per week, used to be more).  The same love/hate relationship exists for that too.
I am a 330lb man who just recently took up running. After breaking my back 4 years ago I have put on 25lbs a year and must now reverse the process. I have a true love hate relationship with running. I love to run naked thru down town Seattle and most people seem to hate it. I completely understand where New Balance is coming from. Its about time that a company realizes (or admits to)the true nature of thier product.  
I have been a hardcore athlete the majority of my life.  Everything from biking to bodybuilding, and even though running hasn't been number 1, it has been a big part of it.  New Balance gets it.  Any serious athlete will love this commerical, no matter what the sport. As far as the odd world, maybe what New Balance is saying is that running takes you 'somewhere else'.  I'm sure any serious runner is not focused on the running, but their mind is in a very different world when the run....I know mine is, its the only way to enjoy it.  Put your mind on the pain and pavement and your sunk.
Thanks for the comment Karl.
I know what they mean about the love hate relationship.  I have wide feet and buy NB because they are the only shoes, that do not tear out along the sides before they need to be replaced from normal wear.
My first impression was that NB gets it.  I run a 10k at the beach 2 nights a week at sunset.  I hope the sky and water are red, what do they say... Red sky at night, runners delight.  Red sky in the morn runners take warn? Something like that
my husband and i are both runners and we loved the commercials. the love/hate concept is perfect. i think the author of this review is getting a little too hung up on the concepts (i.e. does the red water = global warming?) it is supposed to be fantasy...when you run your mind goes all over the place. i can't wait to see more new balance love/hate ads. you feel like they must make good running shoes if they know that much about what it's like to run.
I'm not a runner but I am a guy gets up at the crack of God's ass to get to the gym before work.  I think anyone who is remotely athletic and works out, especially an early morning torture session, will totally get this!  I think it's time for me to go shopping...
"... why inject fantasy into the mix? The commercial leaves the viewer with too many far-flung questions:  Who are those other, slightly menacing-looking runners? Did global warming make the ocean red?"

Obviously Allison Linn is not a runner.

The "fantasy" setting with the warped buildings is pretty much my world view toward the end of a long run, when I'm tired, everything does seem somewhat skewed to me- maybe because my attention is so internalized.
The other runners are competition, of course.  And people coming up behind you is menacing anyway.
To me, the color choices make perfect sense - red is the color of passion, both negative and positive - and who hasn't "seen red" as you struggle to finish a run or other tough workout? (Again, obviously not Ms Linn).

This is a great ad, and not just because runners can relate, but because the entire theme drives home "Balance" -reminding you of the company the ad is advertising.  Unlike many ads today, its clear and straightforward and you never forget what you're supposed to buy at the end.
Haven't seen the commercial but will look for it.  Show me a person who swears they love to run and I'll show you a liar.  But enough from me, I gotta get some miles in....
love nb...but to the writer and New Balance (especially)--why not a HEROINE?

c'mon. Women run, too!!!
I am in the Army.  I run because I have to.  As I get older, I find that it never gets easier or less painful.  I find the direction of this advertisement right on target however.  If you set out to lay down some miles at the crack of dawn (as I do), and it never gets easier, you have to have a strategy.  I find the best strategy for me is to tune out the pain and the minutia of my individual steps and focus on the landscape and the bigger picture.  As an Army soldier, I always concentrate on situational awareness too.  The runners around me get younger all the time (relatively), which I find slightly menacing as well.  In the big picture, running is much like this advertising portrays as a step into the surreal.  Wouldn't trade it for the world!  In real life, those soldiers are my friends and comrades and we are running together not against each other.  I started wearing NB's twenty years ago when they advertised that they stocked all sizes of shoes (I wear a 4XW). I like the grey cross-training models because they don't show the dirt as much.
The ad caught my attention right away. Obviously written by a real runner. I'm not necessarily hard core. It captures the sentiment perfectly: I want to do it. I need to do it. I hate doing it. I love doing it. I can't stop doing it. I am better when I do it. Long term, I will reep the benefits. Right now, it sucks. Later, I will be glad I did it. It clears my mind. It makes me crazy. You have to be a real runner to understand this relationship. Some days I don't want to get out there, and even after the endorphins kick in, I don't feel any better, and yet I am glad I made the effort. So far, no major injuries. I'm looking forward to getting better and becoming "hard core". I understand it is a process and rome wasn't built in a day.
Odd... no one commented that the 'buildings that defy gravity' are letters that spell out the word "LOVE".  I guess subliminal advertising really does work.  (sometime, when watching one of those cell-phone commercials where they keep talking about all the 'bars' of reception you get, pause the TIVO and count all the visual images of escalating bars.)  

Subliminal.  Clever.  

The water is red because, well, it's red when the sun comes up on the puddles you run over, blood is red, anger and frustration is red, and you run right past them... lots of reasons.  Global warming? c'mon.
Yea, funny no one caught the buildings spell the word "LOVE" in the background.
Also, Fartlek is a sweedish word, translated to mean "Speed play".  Which was mostly well described above by some posters.  It is a form of tempo running with varied speeds over varied distances throughout your run.
Also, red is about passion, but is ALSO New Balance's corporate color (I think)
Did no one notice the ridiculous amount of ads placed in these comments?  I totally understand the need to spike your sales, but STOP HIRING PEOPLE TO POST COMMENTS THAT AREN'T TRUE OR GENUINE
I used to run 3-5 miles a day and never found shoes that were comfortable!  I ended up in heavy boots and tried to find dirt or sand to run in so I know of the love/hate thing.  But maybe it was the low arch in both feet that was the problem? humm....  
Once a friend of mine asked me...Why do you like to run?  I told him because I have this love/hate relationship with it. I hate go out running, but once I hit the road is all but love.  I saw this ad, and I was like wow, it is so true.  I just got a new pair of Nike + shoes, with the sportband, which I love  the whole Nike + experience, but I am missing my Adidas Adistar, I am even thinking of making a hole in my adidas to put the nike sensor in it, and see if I can get the best of both world.  Good running shoes(adidas)and thoughtful idea (Nike +).
Every building is spelling out LOVE in building shaped letters nothing futuristic here... I love running and these shoes have worn them for years. If my knees had not given out I would still be running at 60...
Yes! I ran in New Balance shoes for a year, but then switched to Asics and now am running in Mizunos. They really should have gotten a person who ran to do this review, after all, only runners will ever know that things really do look like that when you run. Most people see red as symbolizing pain, and take it negatively; runners have a weird way of embracing pain and so the image is appealing. My Cross Country shirts say it best "Pain is my Best Friend" and "My sport is your sport's punishment".


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):