ABOUT ADS OF THE WEIRD

With Ads of the Weird, MSNBC.com takes a look at some of the oddest, most eye-catching, controversial and just plain interesting advertising out there today. Primary writer Allison Linn covers the retail and advertising industries for MSNBC.com. The Ads of the Weird team is always interested in hearing what ads have caught your attention, whether it's online, on television or in print.


A Monster disappointment

Posted: Tuesday, March 18, 2008 3:00 AM by Allison Linn

As if there’s isn’t already enough pressure on us not to disappoint our parents, now along comes Monster to tell us that the stork who “delivered” us is seriously questioning whether it wasted its time, as well.

The job placement firm’s recent commercial features a stork making an arduous journey over sea, mountains and desert, even battling other wild animals and a nasty storm, all in the pursuit of bringing its precious cargo to the doorsteps of a Volvo-driving couple.

Fast-forward two or three decades. The baby that endured the stork’s breathtaking journey is now a grown man sequestered in a drab office, a box of takeout on his desk, looking bored and slightly forlorn. And that’s before he sees the stork through the - of course, rain-spattered -window, a look of utter disappointment on its face.

Monster

The commercial is meant to inspire us to reach our potential and do something meaningful with our lives. The implication, of course, is that you will attain this higher level of meaning by finding that perfect job on Monster’s Web site - and not just another crappy job that pays a bit more or maybe has better coffee.

The ad definitely gets a viewer’s attention with the stunning cinematography, and a cute baby never hurts, either. But while some may find the stork’s silent disapproval to be motivating, others may just see it as a reminder that so many jobs are like this ad’s hero: full of promise but, in the end, such a disappointment.

Monster says it isn't planning to air the commercial until later this year, but the company is previewing it online. To watch it on the Web, click here .

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

WOW...Right to the heart!
These message boards should be after every news story.  Let's hear what the people have to say..
I think it is beautifull and sent a clear message from Monster: We are there to help you find the right job fo you!
WOW - that really is a great commercial, but does monster really deliver?
I did see this spot on tv.  It looked great and really stood out.
Great commercial, but from what I've seen from Monster, from my own personal experience, their service doesn't quite match their advertising.

Get them both right and you'll completely monopolize on the job search industry!
I really like this commercial.  It's way better than the one with the guy who works at a Kinkos-esque store who sees himself walk in and is thrown over his own shoulder and carried out.  Or is that a Career Builder commericial?
So I have to go to a website and get another job to avoid disappointing a mythical bird?  Whatever.
Wow.  I just saw the commercial and I'm impressed.  We need more decent ads like this...something to maybe actually entertain us during the breaks on TV.  You might not like the company or whatever, but the actual video clip is nice.
I have been trying to use Monster for several years but for the most part the jobs are the same companies and jobs over and over again.  Leading me to believe that the jobs that are posted are ones that nobody wants for very long.
I thought it was a great commerical
Monster talks a great talk but only seems to have IT, HR and engineering positions.  What about all us other university educated, experienced types that get ignored by HR types?  I would find a more fulfilling job too if Monster could find me one.  There is a challenge Monster!
Commercial is ok. I wonder if I would have "gotten it" completely had I not read the article first. My biggest issue with Monster is that it doesn't work very well. As someone with experience as a recruiter and an HR Director, I must say they have a lot of catching up to do with CareerBuilder.
IT fails to mention the jobs that monster advertises are most likely those similar to one the guy looking out the window has now.  Hundreds of applicants, but whoever is willing to take the lowest salary gets the job.  
Hey Helen, Montana, just FYI, the stork is not "mythical" - they really do exist.  
Monster got me mostly scam job offers.
CareerBuilder is better for real IT jobs.
I agree with Mr. Buchanan of Lipan, TX.  Until reading this article, I'd completely forgotten my search on Monster!  I used them back in 2001/2 and found nothing...no one ever "found" me either!

Thankfully, there is still networking the old-fashioned way, word-of-mouth, and who-you-know!
Marge, it's OK if you didn't understand Helen, the rest of the world did. Anyway, as a baby, I was delivered by a turkey buzzard. I loved the commercial but when I need a new job, I get it the old fashioned way. Thanks anyway monster!
Funny, I found my dead-end cubicle job through Monster.
an amazing commercial that really hits at the core of the human spirit....but also a sad commentary of how many people don't love their jobs and their professional life is mundane.
Remember, Monster is just providing the forum, but it's up to the job poster to truthfully represent their available position(s).  It's not Monster's fault if posters mislead job seekers by positively exaggerating the position and throwing in sexy keywords and catchy job descriptions when, in reality, the job involves a cube, 30 minute lunch breaks, and 24 hr suicide watch.
What matters most is not your job. You are not your job. You are not how much money you have in the bank, or what you drive, or what you live in. At the end of your life, only you will know if you lived it well or not. Office jobs may be a sad fact of modern life, but the job does not have to dominate your life. Better yet, find your passion and figure out your own path. A horrible job lead me to develop my photography career, and it's what I do today
All I got was scam job offers also. I was hounded for about a month until I had my information removed.
All I've ever found through Monster was Ponzi schemes, temp agencies, and jobs with turnover so high that even in a recession they're always hiring.  I've got a great job at a bank thanks to the old-fashioned way; an ad in the Sunday Reno Gazette-Journal.
As I have gotten older, it sounds like my life in a nutshell. My empty carryout box is in the trash beside my desk.

Waiting for the holiday off....
Hey DB in Boston... " in reality, the job involves a cube, 30 minute lunch breaks, and 24 hr suicide watch. " ...  Ya mean there's more to life than THAT???  That's all i've ever known and have had 8 jobs in my lifetime...   WOW
I like it! I beleive people will stop and watch it. Some Will get it and others won't. I also felt like  it would make good advertising for lots of products. It could also be used with a few small changes to  Kudo's to the advertisers. Would like to see them do some for drugs, smoking and drinking.
I also got my over promised and underdelivered job through Monster.com.  I'm sorry I read this article.  Now I'm depresssed.  Work isn't meaningful; its just a necessity.  This world and the people in it suck.  
IMO, the measure of our worth is not in the job that we do.  Our value is separate from any job or work that we do.  Thus, Allison's commentary about disappointing our parents and even the stork leads us in a direction that is unnecessarily bleak and also untrue.

With that said, it is indeed very sad that so many people are working in jobs that are inconsistent with their human potential and jobs that they find unrewarding.  Are we sometimes contrained by the economic "engine" or are we sometimes constrained by the expectations we place upon ourselves (e.g. "I need to take a cubicle job so I can earn enough for that SUV.")

For people who are unsatisfied, I wonder if part of the solution might be to engage in work that is more focused on helping other people.  I am even thinking of volunteer organizations.  There might be less money in these roles, but maybe sometimes we can reach far more of our potential when we "think outside the box" to focus on helpng others around us.

Monster has worked out well for me. I've been fully employed for some time now. Both jobs in the past 5 years were from my resume on Monster. And, since recruiters continue to send me e-mail, I know there are more jobs out there in case I want to move again.
Well, let's see...the stork travails to deliver his cargo (allegory for labor, as in the childbirth kind) through wind, water and wolves, and succeeds in his task. Flash forward to the adult that the child has become, alone in a small, dreary space, with nothing but the rain outside his window to look at...until the stork appears again in his life, through the glass. It's hard to tell exactly what, if any, expression the stork has on its face, but the man stares back at it...as if he somehow recognizes the stork from some prenatal memory, as if he has failed at some karmic task foreordained centuries ago.

I don't know what ad agency produced this commercial, but it is powerful and beautiful in the allegory of the stork, and all downhill from there. Where the agency blew it was failing to show what action the man took after seeing the stork. What's the point of having a "Eureka!" moment if there's no denouement?

As for me, I've gotten a couple of cube-dweller jobs through Monster. I think they should stick with improving the quality of the jobs and employers they offer on their site and leave art to the artists.
Our jobs are a neccesity. What we choose to achieve in life is at our own discretion. If you settle at a meaningless job that's your own fault, not Monsters. I've tried Monster out, but they didn't advertise anything that suited me. I looked elsewhere, but that doesn't mean anything. You get the good with the bad.
We're brain washed sheep.  Our whole country is rich to the point that the biggest health problem among our poor is obesity, and yet we are never satisfied with our jobs, careers, spouses, lives, anything.  They chose a good name:  Monster...Greed.
this ad has produced a pretty interesting range of thoughts - so at the very least it's been stimulating - the world of work is a personal, complex, everchanging thing - sometimes it's all about the money, sometimes it's all about new experiences - but ultimately it's about having a go - good luck y'all
If you measure your worth by how much money you make,'It will never be enough', concentrate instead on becoming a worthwhile human being, help the ones in need, clean up your life, become a 'giver instead of a taker'--- live,learn, love and laugh!, you will become a happy camper in no time at all!
Screw Monster.  I used Career Builder and I love my job.
Monster has always been a huge help in me landing interviews with decent companies.  What they really need to do is improve on there "houscleaning" meaning they need to go in every once in a while and clear out the old stale job ads that have already been filled and that are just taking up space so people don't think they are still open and continue to keep applying with false hope.  I say this with experience as I've been out of work for 4 months ( just got a job) and know that some ads have already been filled but are still on Monster as open in my area.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):