ABOUT ADS OF THE WEIRD

With Ads of the Weird, MSNBC.com takes a look at some of the oddest, most eye-catching, controversial and just plain interesting advertising out there today. Primary writer Allison Linn covers the retail and advertising industries for MSNBC.com. The Ads of the Weird team is always interested in hearing what ads have caught your attention, whether it's online, on television or in print.


TMI from Dove

Posted: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 3:00 AM by Rob Neill
Filed Under: ,

Dove’s “Campaign For Real Beauty” has been the source of good advertising with a good (if a tad bit Oprah-ized) message for a few years now.

 

The message: Women should be comfortable with their bodies and own beauty. Hopefully it has made some people feel better, more respected and respectful.

 

Certainly, though, women are still hit with contrary messages at every turn. The company’s new “short film” (or is that “long ad?”) is especially striking.


Unilever

 

“Onslaught,” created by the campaign by agency Ogilvy & Mather opens with a doe-eyed young girl staring into the camera, as if she’s waiting to be told something. What follows is about 50 seconds of rapid-fire edits and dissolves that show what the world, or at least the world of advertising, will be telling her throughout her life. And how she may live her life because of it.

 

Advertisements for lingerie dissolve into fashion magazines dissolve into diet pills dissolve into beauty creams dissolve into an emaciated woman piling on weight and back again dissolve to a bulimia sufferer dissolve into various plastic surgeries.

 

When the commotion dies down, the camera refocuses on the girl with the message “talk to your daughter before the beauty industry does.”

 

Show the evidence. Deliver a simple message. Very effective.

 

Of course Dove is owned by Unilever, which makes the really-it’s-a-magic-pheromone-and-not-cheap-drugstore-cologne spray Axe. And more importantly markets it like this. We’re far too polite to at this point bring up talking out of both sides of one’s mouth. So we won’t.

 

Apropos of nothing: We really liked this completely unrelated ad. Reminds us of when Tarantino made good movies.

 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good spot, almost as effective as Evolution campaign.  It makes me sad to think about how we perceive beauty these days...especially as I sit here in discomfort from just having plastic surgery that I really didn't need :?/
Not only magazines, diet pills and celebrities makeus owmen insecure; it's also the men in our lives that tell us that we need to be skinny, the men wholook at porn because they aren't satisfied wit hthe beautiful women they are in a relationship with. Men, it's time to get realistic.
I find it very telling that most of the comments on ads of the weird are numerous...but not this. this is a great commercial.
Let's not forget that what Dove is doing is advertising.  They aren't really out to change the world, they're out to sell soap.

Those in the Dove marketing department have detemined that this ad campeign is effective at reaching their market demographic.  That means they sell more soap with it.

I'm sure that if they found that a campeign advising prospective customers to rub their product directly into their eyes worked well, they would just as soon do that.

I, for one, can't really blame them.  It could be a lot worse.
I've had an eating disorder... It was not pleasant.
If there is one thing the world doesn't need, it's the beauty industry. There are no ugly women.
Keep in mind, parent company UniLever is also the genius behind Fair and Lovely, a "lightening" cream marketed at women in Asia and India so that they can be more "white."  

While Dove's feel-good campaign touts itself as the bastion of social responsibility, its global hyper-capitalism promotes a morality completely at odds with its messages.
Why lie? A girl could do everything right, pull A's in school, be great to be around, but if she is fat or chubby, guys don't give her a second glance. It hurts but it does not make it any less true.
Sure, I understand that Unilever is a huge company with lots of divisions and different products. I'm also pretty sure that they've got accountants and marketing and sales people working for them, and if we the people buy the Dove products but don't buy the Axe products, there will eventually be no need for the Axe line, and it'll be...well, axed.
I enjoyed the Dove ads that indicated they were going to revolutionaize beauty ads to show that older is beautiful.  However, they directed viewers to go to their website to see how older is beautiful.  Apparently older isn't beautiful enough to be shown on national TV.  Go figure.
A necessary onslaught if you ask me.  Women waste so much money worrying about our bodies and beauty.  Good health is one thing, but obsessed on a body that will age, change and die is another.  I look at my 3rd grade daughter and her friends, they are so beautiful and innocent.  I can see the media already starting to influence their perceptions of beauty.  All that money spent...could be put to better use as we focus on what is really important.
This ad made me wish I had a daughter to show it to. But wait; why not let our sons be aware, too, of the demoralizing messages women and girls are peppered with every day? This ad is graphic and disturbing enough to make anyone think "I would never want a woman I care about to go through that." I'll show it to my son. He deserves enlightenment, too. Maybe it will make him question the messages he is bombarded with about what it takes to be "masculine."
WOW  What a great ad!!!!!!!!!!!  I was impressed with Dove using normal people in there ads and began purchasing more of their products.  Parents PLEASE listen to the messagaes that Dove is conveying to us.
I just think it's a little backwards to show all of the images we don't want children to see AGAIN to sell the message.
I am not surprised that they are trying to capitalize on both sides of the fence. That is what capitalism is all about. Selling the mouse and then the trap. Aint America grand.
I view the Axe ads as the opposite of the Dove ads. the Dove ads are how women would like to be percieved, for themselves and not some unrealistic ideal. While Axe does the same for men, it hits into the male psyce of how men would love to be thought of as a sexy babe magnet. As a woman I see no problem with the seemingly double message.
I love that this message is targeting your girls, as well as their mothers.  My wish for my grandson?  That he finds someone who is beautiful inside, and doesn't care what appears on the outside.  Wishful thinking at this point in time, but if more retailers pick up on this idea, we might have a chance to stop damaging young girls' lives before their self-esteem completely disintegrates.  I live in Metro Atlanta and there are 10-year olds running around dressed like prostitutes.  Where are their parents, and what makes them think this can be even close to a good thing?  At age 10, I had a vague notion that cosmetics were out there, but Sears was not selling clearly adult clothing in the children's size 6x.  Kid clothing in my size at that time was designed for KIDS.  We are way past closing the barn door, but maybe some of the younger girls out there won't be so eager to run through it if we help them.
I really like this ad.  There are a lot of people out there telling us to make sure our kids feel good about themselves, but this one made me cry.  It really hits home when you think about all of the reality shows where people are completely remade or made to look like a famous person as well as all of the products out there on the market designed to make us 'look better'  What are we doing to our daughters???
It's true though.  I've made a point of showing the ads to my daughter.  She's tall for her age, and thus heavier than other girls her age.  Forget the fact she's has six pack abs from sports, she's still thinking she's fat.  It's crazy.
So, you like a Dale Carnegie ad showing an anxiety ridden youngster going to a class to practice how to get over that anxiety to point a rifle at complete strangers?  Ever hear of Virginia Tech or other incidents?
EWomen are things, they should look pretty for men.
"There are no ugly women."

Um, right. You ever been to the DMV?

There are ugly women. There are ugly men. It is ridiculous to keep hand-holding all of society and expecting nobody should ever 'feel bad' because they don't live up to an ideal.

And women are more critical of other women than men could ever be. Women drive the fashion and cosmetics industry - not men. Stop blaming men for all the failings of women.
mmm... there are certain beauties that both genders are hardwired to look at/for. That marketing campaigns pander to the insecurities of humans shouldn't be a wonder. To say that women don't have the ability to screen out the negative is to take away their power to do it. In the Axe commercial linked to we see some guy looking devastating in a suit. Yeah? I'll never look like that and I hate wearing suits. Do I hate myself for that reason? Not at all. Every day though I am told that men don't know how to dress, I should have sixpack abs, and should make some amount of money or other in order to impress women. It is expected by everyone that I will feel no negative effects from this. The answer to the way the women feel about this stuff is strength from within, NOT taking away external pressures. It is this thing that I arm both my son and daughter with, along with the interest in seeing people in the whole and not just their looks.

Accepting yourself while striving to be YOUR best is a paradox not easily explained to people. It isn't a wonder that not everyone can do it. It also isn't a wonder that marketing companies will find insecurity and exploit it.

The wonder is that people wish to take away the pain, rather than heal the wound.  
Very impressive ad. I wonder if there was a majority of women working on it.  
I appreciate Dove's ads and hope they continue. I am saddened that my bright, beautiful 3 year old daughter tells me she wants to be characters in a book, movie etc of whoever appears the most glamourous. She has picked this up at such a young age. It is difficult to admit but her family has a part in this because we tell her too often how beautiful she is. Instead we should be focusing on her unique qualities and wonderful personality. By us making comments on her looks we are inadvertently putting emphasis on the importance of how she looks.
Dove is the same company that owns Axe shower gel and body sprays, who do the million-girls-running-after-one-average-Joe commercials.  Look it up.  They're not activisting, they're advertising directly to their market.
"Stop blaming men for all the failings of women." Amen, AW.

Attraction is biological, not commercial. People - men AND women - like beautiful people (whatever that means to us individually) because we are human, not because society tells us what to like. Human nature dictates the ad industry, not the other way around.
Advertising only works if you let it.  
Bob - you were'nt paying attention.  Shamey shame shame.  Got a news flash for you.  Lots of guys like girls with a little "junk in the trunk".  So don't speak for the intelligent men out there who can look past media's idea of "acceptable beauty" and know what real beauty is - they DO give them a second glance.  And smarts last longer than what gravity and time will destroy.  Smarts is probably not an issue for you, so I wouldn't waste a lot of time worrying about it if I were you.
"Not only magazines, diet pills and celebrities makeus owmen insecure; it's also the men in our lives that tell us that we need to be skinny, the men wholook at porn because they aren't satisfied wit hthe beautiful women they are in a relationship with. Men, it's time to get realistic. "

Said the fat, ugly broad...
Brutal.
"Not only magazines, diet pills and celebrities makeus owmen insecure; it's also the men in our lives that tell us that we need to be skinny, the men wholook at porn because they aren't satisfied wit hthe beautiful women they are in a relationship with. Men, it's time to get realistic. "

-Not all men are this way, please don't label us all the same.

"Said the fat, ugly broad..."

-Anyone who makes a statement like this is a child (immature at that), not a man.
I'm thinking that if physical fitness were advertised and encouraged as much as the right diet or the right hair color, we'd live in a healthier, and much more physically attractive society. I'm all about being who you are, but there is no reason you can't better yourself in a safe and healthy way so that you avoid obesity and all the medical issues associated with it. People in general need to take better care of themselves. It's okay that not everyone has that pretty face like a movie star, but it's not okay to spend half of your life on a couch eating fast food and other junk food. A well-kept body will go a long way in making you attractive to the opposite sex, even if you don't have a pretty face.
Ok Here is the way I see it. Dove can make any kind of product they choose to and us "Adults" can purchase them for what ever reason to make ourselves "Feel More Beautiful". The thing is that we need to make sure (and I think Dove is trying to make sure) that our children don't come to us at age 6 and say they are fat or ugly because thats what they see everywhere, to be their own person and not to follow society's version of beauty. If they decide later in life they want plastic surgery or diet pills or whatever so be it !! But Dove is  right..Magazines, diet pills and some celebrities need to stop portraying what they say is "Perfect Beauty" and BE REAL !!!
This is a great add. It really depicts the extent to which the beauty industry can sculpt the young mind of a girl. Our society needs to encourage girls to embrace their natural bodies because in truth, the body of every woman is beautiful. The pictures shown in this add are further proof to me of how nuts our society really is.
but the thing is dove and axe are owned by the same company ... thats dumb one side is trying to say dont listen to beauty ads but dove is making an ad rite now and it sells beauty products and axe (owned by the same company) is doing the exact opposite of what this comericial is doing..


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):